The Path to Insurance Counter Fraud

Aug 10, 2025

In Modern Insurance Magazine #73, Matt Gilham talks about his career pathway in counter fraud and why it continues to offer a rich opportunity for new talent.

TALKING RUBBISH?
The path from corporate fraud investigation to insurance fraud data strategy

Twentysomething me stood up to his ankles in reeking bin waste. Blue plastic covers on black oxford shoes, clear plastic gloves and a white mask. The covert operational team had done their job, securing the suspect’s cast out office waste and, as the newcomer to the business, the project team had assigned the review of the search material to me.

It was meant to be clean business refuse, but the stench suggested otherwise. The targeted paperwork was covered in discarded curry. Nonetheless the exercise had been worthwhile, as within the stinking mess was the sought-after evidence: a stolen client list used by an ex-employee to set up a rival firm.

Fast forward thirty years, and now I deal with garbage of a more electronic kind: understanding the data held by clients and how this can be better used to detect insurance fraud. But it’s often no less messy, with challenges remaining in data integrity, completeness, storage, orchestration and availability. It remains a world of “garbage in, garbage out” even in the modern world of AI.

My journey into insurance counter fraud
Like many, I fell into fraud investigation and then insurance by chance. A reluctant regulator after leaving university, I found my aptitude to be spotting patterns in data for insider trading, market manipulation and trading abuse, rather than the oversight of compliance regulations.

With a burgeoning interest in fraud, I secured a role as an entry-level investigator in the world of corporate fraud investigation. And with a natural comfort in using data, quickly developed skills in those early days of pro-active fraud detection and analytics.

But while these skills were honed in the world of detecting bribery, corruption, occupational fraud and embezzlement, it was the world of insurance that created wider opportunity. First, as a technical subject matter expert, then growth through leadership development and subsequent accountability for strategy.

While my personal path is unusual, I’m delighted to see the clear career opportunities that now exist in insurance counter fraud, with more numerous paths than I experienced. And three aspects stand out:

The breadth of roles: From policy validation to claims special investigation and intelligence analysts to data experts, we’ve developed a huge variety of technical and managerial advancement opportunities.

Our collaborative community: An area where insurance simply excels, with unrivalled communication and collaboration between teams, firms and our business ecosystem in data, intelligence and knowledge sharing in a collective goal to reduce fraud.

The appetite for innovation: A sector that thrives on improving capability and transformation and with a now mature approach to winning at both stopping fraud and protecting and benefitting the customer.

So, while I personally fell into combatting insurance fraud, there’s never been a better time or opportunity to attract and develop our future talent.

Matt Gilham

Matt Gilham

CEO

Matt Gilham leads WHITELK with 30+ years’ experience in fraud risk management, insurance fraud prevention and corporate fraud. He helps organisations modernise fraud prevention through strategy, data-led approaches, technology and operational change. Matt also contributes through articles, podcasts, webinars and conference speaking.

FRAUD DATA SHARING IS AN INVESTMENT, NOT A COST

Collaboration has already transformed the insurance industry’s ability to tackle fraud. The next challenge is ensuring organisations are willing to invest in the data sharing that makes it possible. The insurance sector has a strong track record of collaborative fraud...

Can Rebuilding Consumer Trust Reduce the Cost of Opportunistic Insurance Fraud?

Why UK Insurance Has a Trust Problem Insurance has always rested on a simple promise: you pay your premium, and your insurer is there when life goes wrong.  That promise has a name in law – uberrima fides, the duty of utmost good faith – and it assumes both parties...

Assessing the Claim: Can Rebuilding Consumer Trust Reduce the Cost of Opportunistic Insurance Fraud?

An Economic Criminology Analysis of the UK Insurance Market Author: Noah Gilham Abstract This report evaluates the hypothesis that rebuilding consumer trust is a necessary condition for reducing the cost of opportunistic insurance fraud in the United Kingdom. Drawing...

Rethinking What ‘Good’ Looks in Counter Fraud Investment

Successfully measuring meaningful change in fraud performance remains a challenge for insurance fraud leaders. In Modern Insurance Magazine Issue 77, Matt Gilham thinks ‘beyond savings’ to consider what good really looks like in counter fraud investment. Measurement...

Mitigating fraud risk as cyber, insurance fraud and corporate fraud threats converge

When Worlds Collide: Are We Really Prepared for the Convergence of Cyber, Insurance Fraud and Corporate Fraud? Bad actor access to AI has irrevocably changed our threat landscape. Low-cost crime-as-a-service, generation of high-quality phishing emails, fraudulent...

Whitelk at Insurance Innovators Fraud & Claims 2026

Whitelk is looking forward to attending and chairing three sessions at the leading insurance fraud conference Insurance Innovators Fraud and Claims 2026 in London on 24th February. Matt Gilham will be facilitating discussions on topics as diverse and fraud unmasked...

Why Human Judgement Must Lead in an AI World

In January’s Modern Insurance Magazine, Matt Gilham, Director, Whitelk considered how we need to retain ‘human-in-the-lead’ in our use of AI in tackling fraud. I recently published a short series of LinkedIn posts talking through some of the fraud detection tricks of...

From Insurance Fraud to Corporate Liability, Cognitas Global and Lawrie Day

Matt Gilham shares his journey from fraud investigation to running his own consultancy, alongside in-depth discussion on the Economic Crime and Corporate Transparency Act. Together with Lawrie Day, CEO of Cognitas Global, we explore how fraud risk, regulation and...

Driving Collaboration to Tackle Insurance Fraud

Collaboration through reciprocal sharing of data and intelligence is crucial to tackling insurance fraud. In November’s Modern Insurance Magazine, Whitelk explores the continuing importance of reciprocity and how this is central to the Insurance Fraud Bureau’s...

Growing Appeal of Insurance Fraud Careers

September 2025’s edition of Modern Insurance Magazine explored all things around careers and equal opportunities in the UK insurance sector. In the magazine, Matt Gilham reflected on his own career and the growing attractiveness to a career in fraud and insurance...